Three Keys for Effective Abuse Prevention Programs

Child Abuse Prevention

Seldom has a week gone by without a church, nonprofit or school making national news because of the sexual misconduct of one of their employees or volunteers. These allegations consume time and financial resources while destroying the organization’s reputation. Very few things can undermine the mission of an organization faster than the breach of trust an abuse allegation brings.

Abuse prevention measures have changed over the years as we’ve gained more understanding about how these tragic acts occur, the offenders’ behavior patterns, and the organizations’ response activities. Unfortunately, organizations have long believed that these types of issues occur in certain geographies, among certain groups and in certain types of organizations. If the last few years have shown us anything, it’s that abuse and sexual misconduct can occur in any place, at any time.

Historically, abuse prevention programs have centered on making sure outside offenders cannot access the children the organization serves. The assumption was that someone would grab hold of a child and abduct them. The truth is that more than 90 percent of those who report abuse identify the attacker as someone who they know and trust. Abuse prevention programs must adapt to reflect the reality that the vast majority of offenders come from within an organization.

Three Keys for an Effective Abuse Prevention Program

Effective abuse prevention programs include measures for screening potential volunteers and employees, training to identify problem behavior – ideally before abuse occurs  – and systems to report and investigate allegations.

1. Screening

The best way to avoid abuse claims is to have a system in place that helps an organization identify potential offenders. This should include a process that thoroughly examines employee, staff and volunteer applicants. Consider making these a part of your organization’s application process:

  • A written application form that includes questions about the applicant’s experience in working with children
  • A criminal background check that identifies any previous history
  • Thorough reference checks with those who have seen the applicant interact with children
  • A personal interview in which the applicant is specifically asked about any adverse interactions with children and given a clear picture of the commitment of the organization to the safety of children

2. Training

All employees and volunteers should go through training, both at the time of selection and annually thereafter. Successful abuse prevention programs typically include trainings to cover:

  • How to identify grooming behavior
  • Operational measures and policies in place to reduce exposure
  • Reporting responsibilities if inappropriate behavior is observed or if there is any reason to suspect abuse

3. Response

Every abuse prevention program should have clear procedures for reporting suspected abuse and inappropriate behavior. Procedures must include mandatory reporting of all suspected incidents to law enforcement and the insurance carrier, as well as cooperating with law enforcement during their investigation.

Navigating these situations can be complex, so organizations may choose to consider including additional plans in their response procedures for actions like:

  • Working with media relations consultants to establish a communications strategy for internal and public audiences
  • Reviewing, with the guidance of professional experts, their abuse prevention procedures to identify areas to improve

Most organizations have some form of abuse prevention guidelines; however, very few organizations have clearly written programmatic documents that outline all of the steps necessary to protect children and other vulnerable individuals. These programs should be reviewed on a regular basis, especially when the organization’s activities change.

GuideOne understands that insurance and risk issues are challenging. Our goal is to provide policyholders with tools and resources to help keep their hard-earned resources focused on their mission. Because of this, we have an alliance with one of the leading providers of child protection resources. Abuse Prevention Systems and MinistrySafe provide a wide variety of training, including a dashboard-driven learning management system to ensure that all employees and volunteers are adequately trained. They also have sample procedure language and other tools that can help organizations develop appropriate abuse prevention programs. This is provided at a discounted rate to GuideOne customers.

Filed under Church Nonprofit Education
Brian Gleason

Brian Gleason

Senior Risk Manager

Brian Gleason is a Senior Risk Manager at GuideOne Insurance, providing resources and consulting services to GuideOne clients. His goal is to keep his clients' valuable resources focused on their mission.

Prior to his career at GuideOne, Brian spent 20 years in risk management, disaster preparedness, and occupational health and safety for a university in southern California. He has responded to a wide variety of crises including earthquakes, building floods, bomb threats, and chemical spills. He has his MBA and is a Certified School Risk Manager with years of experience consulting with churches and non-profits in insurance, enterprise risk management, human resources issues, and emergency management.

© 2021 The GuideOne Center for Risk Management, LLC. All rights reserved. This material is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to give specific legal or risk management advice, nor are any suggested checklists or action plans intended to include or address all possible risk management exposures or solutions. You are encouraged to retain your own expert consultants and legal advisors in order to develop a risk management plan specific to your own activities.